Sober As A Judge

Sober As A Judge / Case library / Insanity on Trial

Case library · Insanity on Trial

The Burning Bridges

Payne v. State (2020)

Charge: Arson and attempted arsonCourt: Supreme Court of IndianaState: IndianaDocket: Insanity on Trial

The facts

Two historic covered bridges in a rural county were burned, and someone tried to burn a third. A man who had received psychiatric treatment since the age of thirteen, with repeated involuntary commitments and a diagnosis of chronic paranoid schizophrenia, was charged. He was found incompetent to stand trial and was not found competent until eleven years later. The prosecution pointed to his conduct: he acted late at night to avoid witnesses, gave police a false explanation that fuel he had bought was for camping, and produced store receipts as an alibi — signs, it said, that he knew what he was doing was wrong. At trial he testified about a conspiracy of officials who had terrorised him. The defence relied on three court-appointed experts who all concluded his illness left him unable to tell right from wrong.

You have the facts the court had. Guilty or not guilty? Call it in the game with your friends, then see what the court actually decided. Wrong call, you drink.

Citation: Payne v. State, 144 N.E.3d 706 (Ind. 2020)

Read more at courtlistener.com. The source reveals the outcome.

← All cases