Sober As A Judge

Sober As A Judge / Case library / Close Shaves

Shave and a Haircut · Close Shaves

A Razor in the Doorway

People v. Castillo (2024)

Charge: Second-degree murder and criminal possession of a weapon - shooting a man in the doorway of a Bronx barbershopCourt: New York Court of AppealsDocket: Close Shaves

Should the jury have been allowed to decide whether the shooting was self-defence?

The facts

The owner of a Bronx barbershop was in a running dispute with a man over a drug deal. They had a fistfight, and earlier that day the man threatened the owner and his family. When the man came back to the shop, the owner called his friend Jairo Castillo, who came over. In the shop doorway the man confronted Castillo, told him he could not leave, held a razor blade to his face and threatened to cut him 'from ear to ear.' Castillo stepped back, drew a gun and fired six times in about five seconds. Three of the shots, one to the side and two to the back, would each have been fatal. The trial judge refused to let the jury consider self-defence.

You have the facts the court had. Guilty or not guilty? Call it in the game with your friends, then see what the court actually decided. Wrong call, you drink.

Citation: People v. Castillo, 2024 NY Slip Op 05817 (N.Y. Nov. 21, 2024) (No. 102)

Read more at law.justia.com. The source reveals the outcome.

← More from Close Shaves · All dockets